Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mary F Holley's avatar

Careful examination of the underpinnings of Islam, like all religions, comes up with any number of fallacies, contradictions, and leaps of faith. Islam has more than its share and its followers are not unaware of them. The violence and intolerance is an embarrassment to the Muslims I know - all of them physicians - and they cling to the kind and generous hadiths of which there are quite a few.

When someone challenges our religion, into which we were born and had no choice in the matter, they challenge the core of our identity, our relationship with God, our human value to our Creator. To say that is threatening is a vast understatement. Tearing down such a load-bearing wall can cause the roof to collapse. Since the wall is so weak to begin with, Muslims cannot tolerate any self-doubt, and so will defend that wall with every power at their disposal, including violence.

Those Muslims who are focused on Allah, and not Mohammed, can find rich spirituality in Islam, as the Sufis demonstrate. Those who want to nurture their feeling of superiority, anger, insult, and arrogance can fuel that fire with any number of verse and hadiths about the insults, arrogance and violence of Mohammed. Hatred for non-Muslims is cooked into Quran and the Muslims who resist that are strong and successful people who do not need a religious feeling of superiority to maintain personal worth and identity.

Humans crave affirmation and approval. That is why we all seek out people who agree with us in forums like this and form communities of the like-minded. I think we need to find a way to offer affirmation of the Muslim's value to God, admire his strength of family and community, validate his humanity while firmly denying his assumption of superiority over all others, and the violence that ensues from it. We need a Muslim version of the Cosby show on an international level.

Expand full comment

No posts